Planning appeal win for a rural tourism venture and extensions to a residential dwelling in the South Downs National Park

14th November 2025

This successful appeal in the South Downs National Park demonstrates how strategic planning advice, strong evidence, and collaborative design can unlock high-quality rural tourism accommodation and sensitive residential improvements, even in highly protected landscapes.

We are delighted to share that Plainview Planning has successfully secured planning permission at appeal for a sensitive development within the South Downs National Park (SDNP). The application sought: 

  • alterations to a dwellinghouse; 
  • alterations to the attached annexe; 
  • a new, larger holiday let; 
  • and a swimming pool with associated external works. 

One of the key complications on site was its picturesque location near Milland, West Sussex, and within the SDNP.  

Planning for holiday lets in a National Park 

We had originally been involved in the site back in 2021, where we successfully secured planning permission for the change of use of a pub to residential dwelling, along with an annexe.  This previous permission also secured a smaller holiday let building, but following storm damage, a complete rethink was required. 

Our client initially sought support from their architect, to deliver a new, larger holiday let that would provide high-quality visitor accommodation. To achieve this, the proposed building would need to be re-sited within the plot.  This became a key factor that contributed to a subsequent refusal by the South Downs National Park Authority. 

What are my next steps following a planning refusal?  

Following the receipt of the refusal owing to the perceived “impact of the proposal on the character and appearance of the landscape”, we were then approached to assist.  

Our first port of call was to review the refused application, associated plans and cross-check local and national policy to see whether an appeal would be justified, or whether another route, like a planning resubmission, might be more appropriate.   

Given the sensitive design and core supporting documents from the original application, it was clear to us that an appeal was justified.  Through a Written Representation Appeal, we successfully demonstrated that the revised layout and design responded positively to the landscape context and respected the character of the National Park.  

In their comments, the Planning Inspector agreed, concluding that the new building would “…not appear unduly prominent or obtrusive” and would instead contribute to the National Park’s second purpose, which is to promote opportunities for public enjoyment of its special qualities. 

Importantly, the Inspector also recognised that the proposed development aligned with key policies in the South Downs Local Plan, and the Milland Neighbourhood Plan, finding no conflict with the purposes of the National Park designation. 

Team collaboration – a recipe for success 

This appeal success is a prime example of our collaborative working practices. Special thanks go to Phil de Jong at Motion, who provided expert highways advice, and Chantal Foo at Lawson Architecture, whose thoughtful design approach ensured the proposals were both functional and sensitive to their surroundings. 

We are absolutely delighted for our client at the successful outcome, and can’t thank them enough for their kind feedback to us:  

“We wish to express our thanks to all of the Plainview Planning team for all their help and expertise in obtaining a successful outcome in our planning appeal. They were able to quickly identify the key obstacles with our application and provided a clear plan of action for us to follow. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend Plainview. Thanks again for all your hard work!” 

Supporting rural tourism and the local economy 

This decision is a welcome example of how well-designed small-scale tourism accommodation can enhance the rural economy while protecting the landscape and dark skies that make the South Downs so special. It also highlights the importance of clear, evidence-based planning strategy when navigating complex National Park policies. 

Need a planning consultant for a similar project? 

At Plainview Planning, we have extensive experience securing planning permission and appeal wins across the South Downs National Park and other sensitive rural areas. Whether you’re seeking to create new tourist accommodation, adapt existing buildings, or overcome a planning refusal, our team can help you find the right route to success. 

Working with Plainview Planning and McLoughlin Planning  

At Plainview Planning, we focus on helping homeowners, landowners and small developers unlock the potential of their sites. Our expertise lies in housing schemes of under 10 units, householder applications, and boutique commercial projects — where creative thinking and a deep understanding of planning policy make all the difference.  

Since joining forces with McLoughlin Planning in 2024, we’re proud to be part of a wider group of 14 planning professionals and support staff, combining our complementary skillsets to deliver ingenious, commercially-minded planning solutions across England and Wales.  

As part of the McLoughlin Planning Group, our shared objective is simple — to get results for our clients by providing high-quality planning consultancy. Their team of chartered town planners delivers strategic advice and planning solutions across a wide range of sectors, from strategic land promotions and multi-phase residential sites to commercial, aviation, and rural projects.  

For larger, strategic or complex schemes, please contact the McLoughlin Planning team. For householder projects, smaller developments, or boutique commercial sites, our Plainview Planning team would be delighted to assist.  

To speak to us, email enquiries@plainview.co.uk or call 01242 501003 — providing your site address and a brief summary of your project.  

Content correct at the time of publication. For the most up-to-date advice or to discuss your project, please contact our team directly. 

Image source: Lawson Architecture (2024)

Some of our clients

Below are some of the commercial clients and organisations we work with. You can view all our recent projects or read our latest news and updates.